Nuclear Power Regains Respect Among Ukrainians

Despite the fact that the Ukrainian Constitutionnuclear power experts said that this plant would be
declared Ukraine to be a unitary state, the countryable to allow Crimea to develop its power industry,
has an autonomous region to the south. Thisand that the water moderated reactors in rigid
autonomous region is Crimea. The Crimea peninsula ishousings posed no serious threat to the environment.
very different in both economic and political termsHowever, the nuclear power plant was put up for
when compared to the other regions in Ukraine. Butsale, and Crimea entered a lingering period of
the Crimean power industry and its problems closelyelectricity deficit. Many Crimeans suffered a fall in the
resemble many countries that soon regretted theirstandard of living not only because of dissolution of
hasty decisions on shutting down nuclear generationthe Soviet Union, but also because of continuous
projects.energy deficit.
The local electricity output in Crimea accounts forEnvironmentalists fought for the alternative solar and
less than ten percent of the total electricitywind plants. The solar power plant at Scholkino first
generation, and the peninsula could not possiblygenerated electricity in September 1985, but was
satisfy its own demand for power. Crimea receivesshut down forever in September 1994. Its mirrors
electricity generated by the Ukrainian mainland powerare now almost incapable of reflecting light. During its
stations, transmitted along four lines to the region.nine years of operation, the solar plant generated
These transmission lines are:2GWh of electricity, although the project was
• 330 kV Melitopol - Simferopol. - Major linesupposed to ensure an annual output of 5.6GWh.
that provides about 350-450 MW and covers up toThe wind power plant is currently under construction.
forty percent of autumn-winter peak power demandOf the 20 turbine towers planned, the 12 towers of
in Crimeathe Aktash wind power plant have already been built.
• 330 kV Kakhovka - KrasnoperekopskThe plant at Aktash has a total capacity of 4MW,
-Dzhankoi.and it will be a constituent part of the Eastern Crimea
• 330 kV Kakhovka - Dzhankoi.Wind Power System, which is due to have hundreds
• 220 kV Kakhovka - Ostrovskoye.of turbine towers to generate 500MW for the
Their total transmission capacity is limited to less thanCrimea Grid. Eleven turbine towers are installed in
1.3 GW, whereas the maximum demand for electricalDonuzlav. Provision has been made for the installation
power in Crimea was about 1.5 GW in 1993.of turbine towers in the Arabat and Sudak sites. A
As can be seen, the first-mentioned line is overloaded1.2 MW windmill was commissioned at Saki in 2006.
and the next three pass through Kakhovka. TheThe activity around the wind and solar power
Kakhovka lines from time to time face threat ofprojects may give some greens comfort to think
flooding from water storage formerly intended forCrimea will be energy sufficient in the nearest future,
servicing the Crimean Soda Plant. In some cases, thebut that is nothing short of self-delusion when you
transmission poles are only 40-50 meters from thedecide to compare wind and solar figures with the
affected areas. The poles have been in service forreal demand for electricity.
periods ranging between 20 and 40 years, and areThe central Ukrainian government has decided to
said to have very low margins of safety. Shouldtackle the problem by improving the transmission
anything happen to any single pole, then Crimeacapacity from mainland Ukraine to Crimea and by
would suffer a severe electricity shortage.increasing local generation capacity to 400 MW over
When it was part of the former USSR, Crimea triedthe coming four years. Today, the electricity demand
to solve the energy supply problem throughand consumption are actually much lower than those
implementation of the Energy City Project inin early 1990s, but the consumption increased by 30
Scholkino, where three power plants (nuclear, windpercent in 2006 and is expected to exceed its
and solar) were planned. More than a quarter ofhistorical maximum of 9 TWh in 2010 without
century has passed since construction of the nuclearconsidering any sizable investment into the Crimean
power plant commenced (1976), and eighteen yearsresort industry. On the other hand, the Crimean
since construction was terminated in 1989. Theauthorities are planning to build a large network of
former USSR government invested about 550 mln.medium-quality hotels in the near future. What will
rubles or more in the project, i.e. around US$600 inenvironmentalists say in 2010s, when all the air
prices of 1980/84. The 4GW project, as in manyconditioners in the Crimean hotels will work in the
countries, fell victim to environmental concerns. Manysummer and heaters in the winter?